December 3, 2025
How to Handle a Missing W-9 From a Contractor — Even After You’ve Already Paid Them
Updated October 2026
Form W-9 is one of the simplest yet most important documents in your contractor onboarding process. It gives you a contractor’s legal name, business classification, and tax identification number — all information you must have to properly issue a 1099 at year-end. Without it, you can’t file accurately, and the IRS may hold you responsible for withholding or reporting errors.
You can download the official Form W-9 directly from the IRS website, ensuring you’re always using the correct version.
If you forgot to request a W-9 before paying a contractor, don’t panic — this happens to many business owners. The key is taking the right steps now to protect yourself and stay compliant. The swipeable email templates below make the process straightforward.
Looking for more? Find every article in our 1099 series, organized by topic, in The Complete 1099 Compliance Guide for Small Businesses.
In This Article
- Not All “Vendors” Are Companies Exempt From a 1099
- What To Do If You Forgot the W-9
- Email Template: Requesting a W-9 After Payment
- What If the Contractor Refuses?
- Email Template: If the Contractor Refuses
- Backup Withholding: What You Need to Know
- How to Prevent This in the Future
Before You Begin: Not All “Vendors” Are Companies Exempt From a 1099
A common oversight is assuming that a vendor with a business name — like ABC Plumbing or Creative Edge Design Studio — doesn’t need a W-9. But many small businesses operate as:
- Sole proprietorships using a DBA
- Single-member LLCs taxed as disregarded entities
Both of these require a W-9 and, in many cases, a 1099-NEC.
This means that anyone who performs services for your business — whether they use their personal name or a business name — should provide a W-9.
A W-9 is the only way to confirm whether the vendor is taxable as a corporation or something else.
What To Do If You Forgot the W-9
Request the W-9 Immediately
Email the contractor as soon as you realize the form is missing. If they are still working with you, pause future payments until the form is received.
Explain Why You Need It
Most contractors respond more quickly when they understand the reasons:
- You need it to complete required IRS filings
- It prevents errors and mismatches
- It protects both parties in an audit
Document All Attempts
Keep copies of:
- Emails
- Text messages
- Phone call summaries
- Dates and times of every follow-up
Documentation is essential if the IRS ever reviews your records.
Follow Up Consistently
Most contractors respond after a clear explanation and a reminder that their 1099 cannot be completed without the form. The following swipeable templates are ready for you to copy and use exactly as written.
Swipeable Email Template: Requesting a W-9 After Payment
Subject: Request for W-9 Form (Required for Year-End Reporting)
Hi [Name],
I hope you’re doing well. As part of our year-end reporting requirements, we need your completed Form W-9 for our records. This information is required by the IRS so we can prepare your 1099 accurately.
Here is the link to the official IRS Form W-9:
https://www.irs.gov/forms-pubs/about-form-w-9
Please complete and return it at your earliest convenience. If you have any questions while completing it, I’m happy to help.
Thank you,
[Your Name]
What If the Contractor Refuses to Provide the W-9?
If a contractor refuses to give you a W-9, the IRS requires specific action:
- You must begin backup withholding at 24% on future reportable payments
- You must still report all payments you make
- You must file a 1099 using any information you have
- You must keep documentation showing all attempts to obtain the form
Backup withholding must be sent directly to the IRS. The amount withheld is reported on the contractor’s 1099, and the contractor claims it as a credit on their own tax return.
Swipeable Email Template: If the Contractor Refuses to Provide a W-9
Subject: Final Request for W-9 (IRS Backup Withholding Requirement)
Hi [Name],
This is a follow-up regarding our request for your completed Form W-9. We are required by the IRS to have this information on file in order to report payments correctly for tax purposes.
Please understand that if we do not receive a valid W-9, the IRS requires us to begin backup withholding at 24% on any future payments. This amount must be sent directly to the IRS, and you would need to claim it on your own tax return to receive credit for it.
Here is the link to the official IRS Form W-9:
https://www.irs.gov/forms-pubs/about-form-w-9
Please complete and return this form as soon as possible to avoid withholding requirements.
Thank you,
[Your Name]
Backup Withholding: What You Need to Know
Backup withholding requires you to withhold 24% of reportable payments to the contractor until they provide a valid taxpayer identification number.
Backup withholding applies when:
- A contractor refuses to provide a W-9
- A contractor provides an invalid taxpayer identification number
- The IRS notifies you of a TIN mismatch
For payments made in 2026, the 1099-NEC reporting threshold rose from $600 to $2,000, and backup withholding follows that same threshold.
More details are outlined in IRS Publication 1281, which explains backup withholding requirements and compliance steps.
This is why collecting W-9s before any work begins is essential.
How to Prevent This in the Future
- Collect W-9s before issuing any payments
- Add W-9 collection to your new vendor onboarding checklist
- Store forms securely for at least four years
- Track how vendors are paid (ACH vs. processors like PayPal)
- Never skip the W-9 step — even for “small jobs”
- Consider paying contractors through a payroll provider that requires tax info upfront
Good habits early on eliminate most 1099 frustrations later.
Related Articles
- 1099 Filing Requirements Explained: What Every Small Business Owner Needs to Know
- Do LLCs Get 1099s? How to Tell When an LLC Does (and Doesn’t) Need a 1099
- A Beginner’s Guide to Filing Your Own 1099s (Without Paying a Professional)

Do all service vendors need a W-9?
Yes — even businesses with trade names may be taxed as sole proprietorships or disregarded entities, which require W-9s and often 1099 reporting.
Do I need a W-9 if I expect to pay a contractor less than $2,000?
Yes, it’s still best practice. You often don’t know at the start of the year how much you’ll end up paying a contractor, and collecting the W-9 before the first payment means you’re covered if payments cross the 2026 reporting threshold.
Do I still need to file a 1099 if I don’t get a W-9?
Yes. You must file using available information and document your attempts to obtain the form.
Does a PayPal or Venmo payment eliminate the need for a W-9?
No. Payment processors may file a 1099-K, but you still need a W-9 for your records.
What if the contractor refuses to comply?
Begin backup withholding and continue reporting payments according to IRS guidance.
Does the contractor lose the money that’s backup withheld?
No. The withheld amount is reported on their 1099, and they claim it as a credit when they file their tax return. It works like a prepayment of tax.
Is it okay to refuse payment until I receive a W-9?
Yes — it is a recommended best practice.
Do foreign contractors need a W-9?
No. Foreign individuals complete Form W-8BEN instead, and foreign entities complete Form W-8BEN-E.
What if a contractor gives an incorrect or incomplete W-9?
Request a corrected one. If unresolved, you may need to start backup withholding.
What happens if I ignore a missing W-9?
You risk IRS penalties, filing errors, and potential liability for the backup withholding you should have collected.
Fortitude Tax & Accounting, located in Stansbury Park, Utah, just outside the Greater Salt Lake City area, provides tax and accounting services for therapists, realtors, landlords and real estate investors, and service-based small business owners. Led by Melissa Calwell, CPA, EA, with more than 30 years of experience in private industry and public accounting, Fortitude provides tax planning and preparation, bookkeeping, payroll, and practical year-round guidance.
We help business owners understand their numbers, make informed decisions, and approach taxes and accounting with greater clarity and confidence.
Fortitude Tax & Accounting has provided this article for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, business, or tax advice. Tax laws and figures change frequently, and this information reflects the rules in effect when the article was last updated. Each person should consult their own attorney, business advisor, or tax advisor regarding their individual situation.
